top of page
Vermont Business Lab logo
New England Website designer

Direct Booking Website vs. Airbnb: The Math for New England Vacation Rentals

Writer: Ryan Touchette
Ryan Touchette
Oct 22
4 min read

Updated: Oct 24

If you rent out a ski condo, a lake house or a cottage on the Cape, you know the feeling. A guest books, the payout lands, and a chunk of it is gone before you ever see it.


That chunk just got bigger for a lot of hosts. Airbnb has moved nearly every host to a 15.5% fee, and Vrbo moves hosts to a 12% commission starting October 29.


Here's what those fees really cost a New England vacation rental, what a direct booking website keeps in your pocket, and how to go direct without breaking the platforms' rules.


What the Platforms Take in 2026


Airbnb. Most hosts now pay a 15.5% host-only fee on every booking. It comes out of your nightly rate plus your cleaning and pet fees. US hosts who don't use management software were moved onto it on September 15, 2026.


Vrbo. Starting October 29, 2026, Vrbo is moving hosts to a flat 12% commission that includes payment processing, with rates from 12% to 15% depending on region. Guests still pay a separate traveler service fee on top.


The pattern is the real problem. In about a year, both platforms changed what they charge, and hosts didn't get a vote. When you rent your booking engine, someone else sets your margin.


The Math: One Booking, Four Ways

Take a four-night ski weekend at $400 a night plus a $200 cleaning fee: $1,800 before taxes.

Booked through

Fees

You keep

Airbnb (15.5% host fee)

$279.00

$1,521.00

Vrbo (12% commission)

$216.00

$1,584.00

Your own website (2.9% plus 30 cents card processing)

$52.50

$1,747.50

Your own website, with 10% off for the guest

$47.28

$1,572.72

Read that last row again. You can give a direct guest $180 off and still keep more than you would on Airbnb.

Now scale it up. A rental doing $60,000 a year on Airbnb pays $9,300 in host fees. Move a quarter of those bookings to your own site and you keep about $1,900 more a year after card fees. Move half and it's about $3,800, every single year.


Why Direct Booking Works So Well in New England


New England runs on return trips. The family that skis the same Vermont or New Hampshire mountain every February. The couple who comes back to the Maine coast every summer. The friends who rent the same Cape house every Fourth of July.


Those guests already love your place. The only question is whether they book it through a platform that takes 12% to 15.5%, or through you.


A direct booking website gives them a way to come straight to you, with your own photos, your own story and a returning-guest rate you control for the guests who book with you directly.


How AI Changed the Cost of a Direct Booking Website


Owners rent their booking engine for the same reason restaurants rent their online ordering: custom software used to be expensive. A real booking site with a live calendar, online payments and guest emails meant a development team and a big invoice.


AI changed that. We use AI throughout our design and build process, so a custom direct booking website takes a fraction of the time it used to. That's why we can build it as a one-time project instead of another monthly bill.


AI also handles the guest busywork: confirmation and check-in emails, answers to the questions every guest asks, and reminders before checkout. We build those AI workflows into your setup so they run without you.


What Owning Looks Like


When we build it, you own it: your property's website, your photos and story, a live availability calendar and secure online payments, all on your own domain.


Keep listing on Airbnb and Vrbo if they bring you new guests. Calendars can sync between your site and both platforms, so a night booked anywhere gets blocked everywhere.


A few small costs remain, and you should know them up front:

  • Hosting. On Wix, the plans that take payments start at $29 a month billed yearly.

  • Card processing. About 2.9% plus 30 cents per transaction on Wix in the US.

  • Lodging taxes. On direct bookings, collecting them is your job. Every New England state sets its own; in Vermont, for example, it's a 9% rooms tax plus a 3% short-term rental surcharge, and some towns add 1%. A good booking setup adds them to every reservation automatically.


Play by the Rules: Go Direct Without Risking Your Listing


One warning before anyone gets clever. Airbnb's off-platform policy bans "moving current, future, or repeat bookings off of Airbnb." That means no website in your listing photos or messages, no asking Airbnb guests for their email to market to them, and no discount for booking direct next time.


So don't build your direct business on Airbnb's guests. Build it on your own channels:

  • Your own website, ranking for searches like "lake house in the White Mountains with a hot tub"

  • An email list of guests who booked with you directly

  • Instagram and Facebook pages that show off the property

  • Partnerships with local wedding venues, ski shops and event organizers


Play it straight, and every direct booking is one the platforms never touch.


Questions Vacation Rental Owners Ask Us


Is a direct booking website worth it for one property?

Usually, yes. Every $10,000 in bookings that comes to you directly keeps about $1,260 that would have gone to Airbnb's 15.5% fee, even after card processing.


Can I keep my Airbnb and Vrbo listings?

Yes. Keep them for reaching new guests, and sync your calendars so you never double-book.


Is it against Airbnb's rules to have my own website?

Having a website isn't the issue. Using your Airbnb listing, messages or guest information to send people to it is. Market your site through your own channels.


Who collects lodging taxes on direct bookings?

You do. Each New England state sets its own rates, so your booking setup should calculate them on every reservation.


Do you offer payment plans?

Yes. Projects over $2,500 can be paid in monthly installments.


Pay Once, or Spread It Out


Your rental is an investment you own. Your booking engine should be too. Projects over $2,500 can be paid in monthly installments, so you can start going direct without writing one big check.


Send us last year's payout reports from Airbnb and Vrbo, and we'll run this math on your real numbers.

Request a consultation, or call or text 802-304-0378.

Ryan Touchette, Founder, Vermont Business Lab

Business, by design.


Vermont Business Lab Logo

Comments


bottom of page